Akoya could be left in the water longer to grow 2-3 times thicker nacre but it wouldn't make sense for the farmer. Every month the shells are in the water there is some level of natural attrition, and a pearl with 1.5 mm of nacre will not sell for more than a pearl with 0.5 mm if similar quality.
Also, the longer a pearl remains in the host there's a higher risk of losing roundness, developing bumps or dimples or the worse factor of all.... calcite. All of those will devalue what otherwise would have been perfectly round and more lustrous finishes.
The finest pearls are borne of juvenile growth, much like children have finer skin than adults.
Some of you might ask, why do some larger, older pearls appear lustrous? The answer is simple. Very often oversized pearls will burst from the sack. If the pearl isn't displaced too far from the original sac, it will regrow around the pearl. Although the pearl may be several years old, the newly formed sac is technically juvenile growth.
Even the time of year is critical for harvesting. Late winter/early spring is the preferred time, because e-cells are not tired (for lack of a better term). After long summer growth periods, epithelial cells become somewhat calcitic. During winter, new cells and new growth cycles begin to produce fresher, tighter oriented, more lustrous nacre.
For this very reason, I have suspended harvesting natural pearls during late summer months.
One thing that's not well known is a natural process called "reversion". All living things need calcium. During times of low salinity, storms or cold weather, food sources for mollusks become reduced. When mollusks need calcium and cannot obtain it from food, they'll modify their behavior to gather calcium from their shells. This will actually remove calcitic layers from the previous summer.
I could go on for days how this is an "indicator" for ocean acidification and climate change, but I'll save that for another thread and occasion.
Many people believe "circle pearls" rotate in the sac, but I have more substantiated reasons to believe that's not necessarily the case. I'm certain circle pearls are
partially protruded from the sac more than one time during their life in the oyster. You'll rarely see calcitic circle pearls, even if you're a discerning farmer. They're almost always highly lustrous.