Natural 82.5 carat Abalone Pearl

Thank you for you comments. Yes it is beautiful, unique and a collectors item as it is 1 of a kind. We are very lucky to have it. Hopefully someone out there thinks the same way about it. ( :
 
Lots of great input for you to consider. Whatever you choose to do, it is very beautiful. Thanks for taking the time to get better photos. :cool:
 
Just noticed a pearl on Kari Pearl web site. Its 50 odd carats and shaped like an egg, it seems to be similar colour to our pearl. Says a jeweler in Fort Bragg valued it at around $75000.00. Guy wants $60,000.00. Have been trying to get pick and note onto that site but havent had any joy so far..lol. might try again later today..
 
This is an interesting and rare shape for an abalone pearl (http://www.karipearls.com/large-50-carat-abalone-pearl.html), but the jeweler in Fort Bragg had no business making that evaluation. The true value of that pearl is much closer to $750 than $75,000.

As an interesting side note, why don't you email the owner? He posted nearly four years ago, so I'm sure he's realized what he has by now.
tahoepotts(AT)sbcglobal(DOT)net

Your pearl, by the way, is of much better quality than the one in that photo.
 
Ok will do that.... if I get a reply of what happened to his pearl will let u know.........
 
Those jewelers in Colorado give some of the most exaggerated prices for pearls, Ever. (I am thinking of the Pearl of Allah valued at $62,000,000 by a Colorado jeweler) Seriously, most jewelers don't know pearls at all and say the strangest things.

As I said before, when the price is too high, it doesn't sell. People get the most out-of-sight ideas about what their pearls are worth. That is the pearl mystique. Evryone thinks they can sell their grandmother's pearls in a $$$ pinch and that is rarely true because a once 2k Akoya is selling for $450.00 on eBay, today. The only pearls that hold their value are excellent natural Persian Gulf Pearls.

Perhaps you could list your pearl with Kari for what you think it is worth. She'll keep the ad up for years if it doesn't sell. The person with the 60k pearl does not have a great pearl. The one with the 75k pearls is dreaming. No one in their right mind would pay that for that value. It looks like idiots trying to sell to idiots.

Did you get in touch with Pacific Coast Pearls in Petaluma? They have the inside track on the local pearls and might tell you what you can expect to get if you fiind a customer.
 
Last edited:
Think I was just successful in putting a short note and a pik onto Kari's web site..lol. Sent an email to the owner of the $75000/ $60000 pearl. So will see what feedback we get. We are happy to keep our pearl as it is a 1 of a kind and we certainly wont give it away so someone can make a profit from it. We would only sell it for its true value and the buyer would have to wait for the value to increase or just keep it as a collectors item. Natural pearls will become harder and harder to aquire, especially large pearls as more and more fishing and diving restrictions are imposed in the future to help preserve our seafood industries. ( :
Oops think I might of doubled up posting to Kari's site..lol
 
Last edited:
Now you are talking!! I hope to hear a lot more about this pearl and see even more photos as you continue on this journey!
 
Just put a note to Tish at Pacific coast pearls. Thanks Caitlin, will see what they have to say ( :
Have just read that this pearl that is formed in the body of the Abalone is not as common as the blister type pearls the Abalone produce.
This makes it rarer and more valuble. Prices range from $200 to $2000 per carat depending on quality, I believe the quality of our pearl
is of a high standard , so I guess this info gives us some idea of where its value sits. ( :
 
Last edited:
Jindianna,

No it doesn't. You are again misinforming yourself with misguided research. You are pulling this information from an article written more than 10 years ago by Gary Roskin, describing a hyper-inflated, high retail for gem material. Your pearl is pretty, but look at the back side of the pearl.

The best information you will find anywhere on the Internet is the information you are finding here, from the answers you've received from several pearl professionals that all have experience in either buying or selling abalone pearls. We've also all been to the Tucson show many, many times and have seen sellers with hundreds and thousands of loose, whole abalone pearls of every conceivable size and quality. They simply aren't as rare or valuable as you've been lead to believe.
 
Think about it. Pearl people like jewelry. I would wear that pearl as a pendant, but who else would? Even Liz's 49 carat diamond ring was about unwearable.

Right there you have eliminated 97% of abalone pearls buyers, maybe 99%. What you have left is collectors. What they want is perfection in size, shape, surface, color. Collectors usually have sources who contact them when they have something out of the ordinary. That one is huge and beautiful, but it is far from perfection.

So think about your market. Who could you sell that to? No true collector is going to buy from Karis site unless it is like nothing seen before. You may as well hold onto it as you are highly unlikely to get a retail price. It is not jewelry.

Below are a few shots from Wes and Tish's booth last month at the gem show in Tucson. I see one almost like yours in the lower left of the last picture. Look at them. They are not flying off the shelves. I doubt the Rankins need your pearl but they might give you a price you might sell at if you could find a customer. The fact is, is is very hard to find gem quality abalone pearls, the rest just pile up, unsold. That box was not his top of the line box, that one is on the top left and all of them are smaller and more colorful.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0216.jpg
    IMG_0216.jpg
    20.9 KB · Views: 76
  • IMG_0217.jpg
    IMG_0217.jpg
    36.9 KB · Views: 82
  • IMG_0211.jpg
    IMG_0211.jpg
    42.6 KB · Views: 76
Last edited:
Hi guys and girls, sure is drumming up some interest..lol. Jeremy give me a valuation you certainly have a greater knowledge than I have and yes I only know what I have read or what jewelers have told me.
Caitlin a valuation from you would also be appreciated.
Thanks in advance.
Jindianna
 
Hi guys and girls, sure is drumming up some interest..lol. Jeremy give me a valuation you certainly have a greater knowledge than I have and yes I only know what I have read or what jewelers have told me.
Caitlin a valuation from you would also be appreciated.
Thanks in advance.
Jindianna

Hi,

If you read the older posts in this thread, you'll see Jeremy saying the value of the pearl is close to $750 and Caitlin is saying app. $20/carat. But you can always see if you get more then lower your price if it not the case. I think the kind people here are trying to keep you from getting too disappointed.

- Karin
 
Hi,

If you read the older posts in this thread, you'll see Jeremy saying the value of the pearl is close to $750 ...

- Karin

I wrote that the value is closer to $750 than $75,000. It is worth more than $20 per carat though as it does have nice color. $100 per carat or even slightly more would be fair wholesale if the edges are sealed and there isn't any cracking or peeling present anywhere on the pearl. If any of those problems exist the value per carat would drop dramatically.

The market is soft for baroque pearls and strong for pearls with nice symmetry. Although the pearl's color is nice, it is a baroque pearl and it's thin. That combination equals a difficult sell.
 
One has to consider its possibilities for use. My point is that it is too big for most people to want it for jewelry- except maybe a belt buckle. So its value is only to collectors.

There aren't many collectors compared to people who wear jewelry. It is a difficult niche. My guess@$20 per carat makes it about $1,700 retail. That is a wild guess trying to respect its rarity.

And paying that, it would still just be a paper weight, or a display object. In my opinion, it is best off being your paper weight. The story is fabulous from the moment you found it to the difficulties in actually selling it.

I am sorry if I sound discouraging. I don't mean to say it isn't possible to get far more for it, it is just unlikely you will be able to find a buyer and it should probably be someone who knows nothing about abalone pearls. So try to get your jeweler or another one like him, to buy it. Consign it to someone like that, who will showcase it and say it is worth $100k. Knowing the truth is not helping your cause at all.

Jeremy said it was thin. So we never saw photos of its sides. If so, a belt buckle just might do it.
 
I think Caitlin is right about pearl lovers generally being people who like to wear their pearls as jewelry, rather than display them. Wearability is a huge factor.

I also agree with her suggestion that you consider keeping it-- it is a very cool conversation piece!
 
Ditto to Pattye, I can also see it as a pendant. Also not in my budget, but it is lovely. selling it to a jeweler that has very high end clientele would be your best bet at getting a high price. There are also some rock, mineral and gem collectors that like to add unusual pearls to their collection, that could be an avenue as well.
 
( : Yes it is perfect for making a pendant. It is 40mm long 30mm wide and 8mm thick. I will follow up with Claudia's jeweler to see what he can do. It has been sitting in a drawer for quite some time, so guess I might aswell do something about it.. Thanks again for your input.
 
Back
Top