The good people at Tahiti Pearl Market have been buyers of ours too for quite some time. There is an excellent chance you saw some Kamoka pearls when you all stopped by their booth.
Maybe that's why these match. I bought 2 of them at the Faire during the ruckus. I had mixed emotions, but they were beautiful and the guy told me he knew Josh, and that the pearls had come from Ahe.
Sunday I went through Josh's stash (somewhat depleted by our Host with the Most) and knew I had found a good one when Josh asked, "Where did you get that pearl?" and then called Sarah over to look at it. The 2 Pearl Mart pearls are rounds and perfect for studs. The Kamoka is actually a baroque with a large round top (sort of light bulb shaped) and perfect for a ring. Can you tell which is which?
P.S. Even more amazing in person!