Casey: Just when I was ready to stop drinking coffee and playing on the computer, I saw your post!
Ok, this one last thing then I'm turning this off!
Stauchura: love them! Mary and Ellie are very helpful. I really do think their prices are very reasonable. I've purchased mostly pearls from them, but the rare sundry item as well. Pearl purchases are SSP and freshwaters. I haven't bought akoyas or tahitians. They just initiated a 30% restocking charge. They will send you positively HUGE photos on request. So much so, there's not a dimple or blemish that you can't see before you purchase.
As far as their grading is concerned, use your best judgment. They don't grade on the A, AA, AAA system. They use verbal descriptions. I bought the Mother's Day special from Pearl Paradise in AA quality and I've wanted to purchase some of those wonderful freshwaters Stauchura has for comparison/grading translation purposes. But my funds are far too tight.
They are constantly upgrading their stock. The freshwaters you see on their site now weren't there 5 years ago. If something looks like what you want, but the quality looks a bit off, hold off buying. They will eventually stock precisely what you're looking for. Patience is on your side.
Pearllunar: Haven't purchased from them, but I think Ivonna has.