Hi GemGeek,
Your name "GemGeek" finally run a bell with me. What a great ID name.
But when I first joined the Pearl-Guide Forum I was totally ignorant. What I have learnt from this site is truly amazing and this drives one on to learn more and more from every site possible but the truth is that this is the best site out in cyberland for learning about pearls.
I realise that experts do not want to stick their necks out but I have found that it is possible to make a educated guess or opinion on natural pearls. Not saying I don't make the occasional mistake but natural pearls do look different to cultured pearls. Mistakes are few and far between.
My collection of antique pearls (naturals) is based on experience, having a good eye for naturals and also what I have learnt from this forum. Study has been done by looking on a regular basis and I would say I have a 95% chance of being correct in my assumptions. I do also realise I cannot resell any such pearls as 100% natural unless I get a certificate.
But then even with all the technology pearls have been stated as being natural until too many came onto the market and the whole testing came into question. It is always a learning process as we know.
My reason for being sure on most of my "naturals" are that they are all antique and the recent sham/scam natural pearls are recent. I do not buy modern so called naturals. I do buy antique pieces and if I had them I would bet my balls on items I am sure of as being natural, actually being the real thing.
Then there are the pieces I am not 100% on and these I would never try to resell as naturals even though they might be. Others I know the moment I see them that they are not naturals. Whwen and if I sell Antique Natural Pearls as "natural" it will be 100% sure they are just that and will give a guarantee to that effect if I do not have the documentation. Naturally prices of said naturals would also be lower.
Although I sell, so far I have not listed many of my natural pearl pieces. When I start up my own site I will list quite a few. Although not all as I really find it hard to part with naturals. That is the reason why on my eBay site I have listed and still am listing slowly all of my Akoya, SS and Tahitian pearls. Apart from the occasional piece such as my big Beautiful Akoya Baroques on another thread not long ago. I also really love some south sea pearls, especially those with organic, funky shapes. Some of those I will keep too and maybe a Cortez, Tahitan etc. Just not too many.
I do have more photos of Mexican pearls mainly in brooches or earrings which I could post if anyone is interested. Some really beautiful, just need to find them in my pearl colletion photos which takes up loads of space
Dawn - Bodecia
eBay Seller ID dawncee333 - natural pearl collector and all round pearl lover.